Thoughts on Racism in Vermont (and Elsewhere)

by Rob Roper

Two racism related stories have rocked Vermont in recent weeks. The first had to do with campers being taunted from a passing car in Stowe, and the second with Rep. Kaiah Morris’ decision not to run for office again due to race-based harassment. Neither of these incidents is acceptable, but how we handle them can either help or make worse the situation. Sadly, the emerging “Social Justice Warrior” approach to solving racism is actually making matters much worse by insisting that everything be seen through the prism of one’s skin color.

It used to be that teaching people not to see race was the way to wipe out racism. As Martin Luther King, who has some authority on this subject, said of his Dream, “children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character.” But, now we are told that his vision is actually racist. Speech codes on college campuses, for example, list, “There is only one race, the human race,” as a racist micro-aggression. (What?!) In fact, now you must see someone’s skin color in order to affirm their racial experience or you’re racist. Yes, this is some serious Orwellian “War is peace, freedom is slavery…” thought twisting going on here. Sorry, but if we’re picking a path to solutions, I’m sticking with Dr. King.

We’re also told now that asking someone, “Where are you from?” is a racist micro-aggression. This was part of the Stowe complaint. Staff at the hotel where the campers were staying asked them where they were from in an attempt to be friendly. It is a logical question in a hotel in a tourist town where everybody is from somewhere else. It’s an easy icebreaker. As the vice president of the hotel in question said, “My staff is trained to talk to people and ask them where they are from, what are they doing here, and what’s the purpose of their meeting. That’s customer service.” If it is considered racist to introduce ourselves to one another and ask basic questions about each other, how will we ever get to know one another and realize we like one another?

The concept of “cultural appropriation” is another unproductive trend. Sharing aspects of diverse cultures is, again, a way to get to know and understand people who are different from ourselves. It should be an enriching and sought after experience. Of course, nobody should mock or stereotype, but when we see situations where Latina women say only they can wear hoop earrings, or only Indian women can teach Yoga (yup, real stories), we should recognize that these are not cases of insensitivity but rather examples of respect and admiration. By shaming this kind of curiosity and shared experience, all we’re doing is creating walls of racial tribalism and resentment on all sides.

In his book, The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion, Jonathan Haidt, a moral philosopher, explains some of the evolutionary reasons behind tribalism. We are all wired to be wary of that which is different. If we do not know for a fact that something (or someone) is safe, which we learn through familiarity, our survival instinct is to assume that it is not, and prompts us to avoid it. Our primal ancestors who walked right up to the saber toothed tiger assuming it would be friendly were eaten. Their genetics were not passed on. We’re the product of the other guys who hid behind a rock (or killed the tiger first).

Therefore, the solution to racial tensions, Haidt says is to, “Increase similarity, not diversity…. Don’t call attention to racial and ethnic differences. Make them less relevant by ramping up similarity and celebrating shared values and common identity…. There’s nothing special about race. You can make people care less about race by drowning race differences in a sea of similarities, shared goals, and mutual interdependencies.” He later states, “Highlighting differences makes people more racist, not less.” This is why the “identity politics” increasingly practiced by the Left is so dangerous.

A good example finding commonalities to overcome racism is Jackie Robinson and the successful integration of Major League Baseball. People initially rejected the idea of a black ball player because he was different. But, they ultimately overcame this racist barrier by discovering a common love for the game and, if you were a Dodger fan, the common desire to beat the Yankees in the World Series. In politics, we can look to the desire for better educational opportunities for our children, stronger families, safer communities as goals and interests that unite us.

Rob Roper is president of the Ethan Allen Institute.

 

{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

Deanne September 15, 2018 at 3:28 am

Good thoughts, Rob. Well said. I thank my mom for teaching me not to judge by “race,” unlike her father who had no love for anyone not of his “race.” The older I get, the more I see that some of those most similar to me (in some cases, relatives even), can’t be trusted or believed. Everyone has to be given a chance based on their own merits – not their “race,” who they’re related to, where they are from, or anything else.

As far as the statement about there being only one race, the human race… I believe that is true, and if that is considered racist, things are really mixed up. And the more I see and read, the more I think that the world really is going crazy.

Reply

William Hays September 15, 2018 at 4:13 pm

Sorry, Deanne. Some people are destined to be silly and prove it.

Reply

Sylvia Hernandez December 1, 2018 at 4:06 pm

I lived in Vermont for 2 years , It is such a beautiful peaceful place to live for the exception of the majority of people who are set in there arrogant ways . The first day we arrived we went to have dinner when we went in , it was loud and everyone seem to be having a good time but the minute we stepped in ,” we got the look” as if we were from another planet . They looked at us like you better turn around . There have been many other occasions when we were out buying groceries when I would find myself telling my husband don’t look at them just look down. I am so sorry for the people that have experienced such hostile , unhuman , racist behavior. I believe most people over there are set in their ways , as a older man said it to me, but you Vermonteers will never get to know us because of your ways . “You might be entertaining Angels” . God put it in my heart if you are not welcome we’re I have send you too dust your feet and move on .

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.
Read more...

Latest News

The Latest Carbon Tax Rigged Deal

January 21, 2019 by John McClaughry This week the House Energy and Technology Committee, chaired by Rep. Timothy Briglin, Democrat of Thetford, is holding four days of hearings...

Millennials Are Getting Screwed by Progressive Policies

January 18, 2019 by Rob Roper Senate Majority Leader Becca Balint (D-Windham) recently penned an op-ed discussing “The Financial Predicament of Millennials.” She opens by quoting a young...

Zupan and Bellini on the carbon tax

January 17, 2019 by John McClaughry  Here two takes on a carbon tax from two very different Vermonters. Lawrence Zupan was the Republican candidate against Bernie Sanders last...

Looking Ahead to 2019

January 16, 2019 By John J. Metzler New York—It’s that time of the year again to consult the crystal snow globe and look ahead at what global political...

One State School District? It Depends.

January 14, 2019 by Rob Roper Someone leaked a memo from the Scott Administration proposing some pretty big changes to the structure of the Vermont public school system,...

Video