The “Kick ‘Em When They’re Down” Carbon Tax

April 2, 2019

by Rob Roper

The Vermont House last week voted 81-60 to double the tax on heating fuels from 2 cents to 4 cents per gallon, and to impose a gross receipts tax of 1.0 percent on the retail sale of natural gas and 1.5 percent on the retail sale of coal. The money raised (an estimated $4.5 million) would be used to increase funding for Vermont’s low income weatherization program.

This action been described by opponents as a “back door Carbon Tax” on fossil fuels.

Supporters of the fuel tax increase are arguing it’s technically not a Carbon Tax because it’s a tax on volume of fuel (gallons) not carbon output (tons released), and that this is increasing an existing tax, not creating a new one. But more disturbing than this semantic jujitsu used to justify (in some cases) a broken campaign promise to not support a carbon tax is the twisted logic that it’s okay to double the tax because fuel prices fluctuate and, therefore, consumers won’t notice.

The scheming goes because the market price for home heating fuels fluctuate, sometimes considerably, the state should use this opportunity to take MORE money out of their constituents’ pockets. If your bill spikes by fifty cents or a buck a gallon, you won’t notice us skimming off another two cents, right?

Yes, this is what they’re saying. And with a straight face! It’s like arguing when your neighbor gets socked with a big medical bill it’s a good time to pick their pocket. From a position of sheer deviousness, I guess they’re probably right. But morally?…

This justification was offered in committee, and on the floor of the house, most aggressively by Rep. George Till (D-Jericho), and can be seen here in this video by Rep. Mike McCarthy (D-St. Albans at around the 1:00 minute mark. Apparently McCarthy’s constituents aren’t buying it!

Rob Roper is president of the Ethan Allen Institute. 


{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

Thaddeus Cline April 6, 2019 at 12:58 am

And 500 people plus who would be cold and loose money paying to keep the pipes from freezing don’t count in your “ book “ and the tons and tons of carbon will not
Keep another hurricane away nor wash away top soil here or as it just did in 3 states . And of course we got the 3 whole country’s that just got flooded out by a cyclone .
No because you don’t care what your children or grandkids will say when they don’t just get it , they are and will suffer from it . Sham on you sham sham sham . Your like any town city or state that has a bridge going and you don’t want to pay for it now because
of a tax so you will pay more when it costs more and will fall down . Your supposed to be the conservatives the ones who want to save money . But we all see , the majority of us in this state that you shoot your self in the foot with your guns by being , (sorry there is no other word I can think of ) Stupid . Now grow up and go back to school and learn how to be a modern thinking person . Your diatribes Are not what most Vermonters believe nor want. Sorry I’m not being more parsimonious on the discibtion of your foolish ideas .


William Hays April 6, 2019 at 2:42 am

Time for Thaddeus to go back to unionized school. Pre-K English would be a good place to start.


Burnham Charlie April 8, 2019 at 2:39 pm

By weatherizing 400 homes a year in Vermont about 1/5th of one percent of the total 240,000 homes would be upgraded. At that rate it would only take about 500 years to come to fruition. Great program, eh?


Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.

Latest News

Commentary: The EV Subsidy Train Picks Up Speed

July 16, 2019 By John McClaughry Chairman Anthony Roisman of the Public Utility Commission has made it official. Vermont is facing a “Pearl Harbor moment”. We in Vermont...

Solving the Border Crisis

July 15, 2019 By John McClaughry During May a record 144,000 people crossed into the United States along the Southern Border, seeking asylum in our country. Not surprisingly,...

Credit Agency: Show Me the People, Vermont!

July 12, 2019 By David Flemming The good news: one of the top major credit agencies applauded Vermont’s legislators for recognizing that Vermont has a population problem. The...

IPCC Hiding Truth on its Failed Models

Testimony of Prof. John R. Christy, U.S. House Committee on Science, Space & Technology 29 Mar 2017 (excerpt) John R. Christy is Distinguished Professor of Atmospheric Science, Alabama’s...

Tunnel vision on carbon reduction leaves Vermont vulnerable to next “climate storm”

July 10, 2019 By Guy Page July 10, 2019 – Vermont’s energy leaders often warn about the dangers of climate-change related extreme weather. But the solutions they propose...