OneCare – Scrap it Now

October 21, 2019

by Rob Roper

After the epic failure of Peter Shumlin’s single payer healthcare scheme in 2014, the next big “reform” that took its place was OneCare, launch date 2016. Many saw this as a backdoor approach to single payer, replacing the single payer with a single provider working within a “global budget,” a set dollar amount per patient not to be exceeded. The promises accompanying OneCare, as with pretty much every promise by government, were that it would lower costs, increase efficiency, and lead to healthier outcomes for participants.

The main idea behind the program is to pay providers a fixed amount per patient, eliminating the “fee for service” model of payment, therefore incentivizing providers to keep patients healthy in the first place, replacing more expensive treatments with less expensive preventative care. The results are coming in, and – shock! – the program has not lived up to expectations.

Cost-wise, the original budget for OneCare was $620.8 million to cover 122,000 guinea pi—er, Vermonters. Today, just two years later, OneCare – the cost saving program — is asking for $1.36 billion, and the right to expand their services to 250,000.

An excellent article in VTDigger outlines just how far off the mark the reality is from the original promises:

  • OneCare is losing money. The model is not profitable (and therefore not sustainable).
  • The number of Medicaid patients utilizing primary care services has dropped. Use of primary preventative care was supposed to increase. That was the whole point!
  • To quote: “The company has also not yet produced any evidence that the initiative has made people healthier. In fact, OneCare performed worse in 7 out of 10 Medicaid quality scores in 2018.
  • OneCare is not realizing savings either through efficiencies or healthier patients.
  • Bureaucratic/Administrative costs are increasing.

The article also quotes various people associated with the program both on the corporate side and the government side as saying one way or another, “It’s too early to tell” if the programs is going to be successful.

Well, flashback to 2017:  “Todd Moore, chief executive officer of OneCare, said everyone involved should have a feel for how well the new approach is working by 2019. If all goes according to plan, he said the new system will cut the annual growth in health care expenditures in half, saving hundreds of millions of dollars over five years and reducing insurance premiums for Vermonters.” (Burlington Free Press, 12/21/17, emphasis added)

2019 is here! In fact it’s almost over. Did OneCare deliver on any of those goals outlined by its CEO? Yes, we now have a feel for how this massive government intrusion into the healthcare market is working. It isn’t. It’s time to pull the plug on this program now, before it gets to be “too big to fail.” There is no way it should be allowed to expand to cover more Vermonters until it has a proven track record of success within its original experimental population. If it can’t deliver there, and it hasn’t, scrap it.

Rob Roper is president of the Ethan Allen Institute

{ 1 comment… read it below or add one }

Paul Scioritno October 26, 2019 at 11:40 am

once again with government, we know better than you!
and lets just throw money at it, whether it’s healthcare, education or new legislation.
money only address the symptoms and not the underlying cause of problems.
solutions are successful when they address the cause and change people’s behavior,
More money and creating new laws does not do that.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.
Read more...

Latest News

Climate Redistribution from Vermonters to Billionaires

January 16, 2020 By David Flemming At least one progressive legislator is willing to admit it: vehicle feebates are carbon taxes. Worse, he admits feebates may not even...

TCI Interstate Carbon Tax Is Imploding

January 15, 2020 by Rob Roper The ink wasn’t dry on the Transportation Climate Initiative (TCI) memorandum of understanding before Gov. Chris Sununu (R-NH) declared it a “boondoggle”...

Vermont Towns in Fiscal Trouble

January 13, 2020 By David Flemming Lately the media has paid some much-needed attention to Vermont’s financial challenges related to unfunded pension liabilities, demographic changes, and labor force...

Attack on and Defense of the Second Amendment

January 13, 2020 by Jeff Kaufman, MD This piece was created as a letter to WVMT radio hosts Marcus and Kurt following an interview segment with Senator Philip...

VT Rep: $15 Min Wage Helps Women…But Would It?

January 10, 2020 By David Flemming On January 9th, the House Committee on General, Housing, and Military Affairs considered the $15 minimum wage bill from 2019. Rep. John...

Video