How DC and Montpelier Encouraged Vermonters to Waste Gasoline

September 21, 2018

By David Flemming

Over the past couple of decades, many American households have become increasingly susceptible to our federal government’s decision to subsidize mixing gasoline with ethanol, a corn based biofuel. Vermont households became particularly susceptible after Montpelier passed a law requiring new tanks for gas stations by 2018.

Like many middle class Vermont households, my family uses a lawnmower to cut our lawn. Before 2008, my dad would get our lawnmower tuned up once a year in the spring, and it reliably carried on into fall.

Around 2008, my family started taking in our lawnmower for repairs a couple of times a year. We may have thought our mower was just getting older, but the repairman diagnosed our recurring problem: the ethanol in the gasoline was gumming up our mower’s engine. After Congress encouraged ethanol production through the passage of the 2005 US Energy Policy Act, gas stations across the country began phasing out ethanol-free gasoline. So, we resolved to never purchase ethanol gasoline for our mower.

And now ethanol-free gasoline is becoming more scarce with each passing year.

By 2016, only one small CITGO that sold ethanol-free gasoline remained within easy driving distance of our house. Fast forward to 2017. I was told by this CITGO’s employees that this would be the last year they would pump gas, including the only ethanol-free gas in our area. When I inquired further, the CITGO employees explained that Vermont’s government had  passed a law in 2013 requiring all Vermont gas stations to replace single-wall gasoline storage tanks with double-wall storage tanks, if they had not already done so. The cost for doing so was too much for the CITGO owner, so he decided to shut down his ethanol-optional gas station to focus exclusively on his auto repair business. I can’t say that I really blame him.

Ted Unkles, coordinator of the Department of Environmental Conservation’s underground storage tank program, says these new tanks cost around $200,000. As assistant coordinator for the program June Reilly frankly admits, “it takes a lot of gas sales to get your $200,000 back.” How much is “a lot?”

Gas stations generally make about $0.03 in profit per gallon that they sell, after operating costs. They would need to sell about 7 million gallons of gas to cover the cost of the new regulation, something few Vermont gas station owners could do quickly.

With its closure, my family’s 2-mile roundtrip to CITGO for ethanol-free gasoline has turned into a 10-mile roundtrip. That annual 100 miles is less than what many rural Vermont families would have to travel to avoid gummed up yard equipment. Regardless, the following estimates will be conservative:

Let’s say that 2,000 Vermont households (1% of the ~200,000 in Vermont) have to drive 100 miles a year to find ethanol-free gas to mow their lawns and use their snowblowers due to ethanol-optional gas stations closing down. That would mean Vermont drivers would end up having to drive an extra 200,000 miles a year. If these cars collectively averaged 25 miles per gallon, that would be an extra 8,000 gallons of ethanol-gas consumed annually. There is no sane reason for this wasted time and expense.

Vermont’s 2013 law would have less harmful if the 2005 federal law had not subsidized ethanol gasoline. Vermont may have ended up with a few gas station closures after the 2013 law’s passage, but since unsubsidized ethanol needed federal law to be profitable, undefiled gasoline would have been far more readily available than it is today.

As it stands, each additional gasoline-related restriction from Montpelier has begun to make the upkeep of our Vermont homes unacceptably onerous.

Only in Vermont could we manage to unintentionally encourage Vermonters to burn gasoline they would rather save, all the while listening to proposals like the ESSEX Carbon Tax which emphasize the importance of using less gasoline.

David Flemming is a policy analyst at the Ethan Allen Institute

{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

Deanne September 29, 2018 at 12:18 am

Well stated. It is government-mandated madness.

Today at work, my coworker (a man-made global warming believer) was condemning Trump’s coal subsidies – and lauding solar and other power options. I pointed out that solar is highly subsidized. He had to admit it.

I find that people cherry-pick the facts and information they like and ignore and avoid what they don’t like. And don’t ask them to follow through to the logical conclusion of what they claim is good policy. Their brains can’t handle the reality.


Deanne September 29, 2018 at 12:25 am

P. S. I am neither Republicrat nor Demoblican, and don’t go out of my way to defend politicians, but the double standard was too much to take: Obama good; Trump bad. Trump has undone the good that Obama had put in motion as far as the international move toward saving the earth…. yeah, yeah…


Ray Thomas September 30, 2018 at 10:20 pm

You can’t fix stupid and unfortunately Vt has an abundance of it! So sad the unaffordable State becoming more unaffordable. Working people cannot afford to live here just the rich and the welfare recipients


Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.

Latest News

Sanders Announces for President

February 20, 2019 by John McClaughry On Tuesday Senator Bernie Sanders announced his campaign for the Democratic nomination for President – despite the awkward fact that he has...

Repeal Vermont’s Estate Tax

February 19, 2019 by Rob Roper Governor Scott and some key legislative leaders indicated a willingness to reform Vermont’s estate tax, raising the exemption from $2.75 million to...

Roll Call! House Blocks Allowing All School Districts to Delay Forced Mergers (69-74), 2019


Farewell to the California Bullet Train

February 15, 2019 by John McClaughry The crowning dream of Democratic Gov. Jerry Brown’s last term as governor was the great bullet train to whisk Californians from Los...

$100 Million Plus Price Tag for Paid Family Leave

February 12, 2019 by Rob Roper Joyce Manchester, a Senior Economist for the Vermont Joint Fiscal Office, testified before the House Committee on General Housing & Military Affairs...