ESSEX Administrative Taxes and the Mind of Homer Simpson

By David Flemminghomer lardofthedance2

The carbon taxers are billing the ESSEX Carbon Tax Plan as “revenue neutral. 100% of the carbon pollution fees will be returned to Vermont electric ratepayers, and the program will be assessed annually by Vermont’s Auditor of Accounts.” This can’t be true because any program carries administrative costs that cannot be returned to the taxpayer. The question here is how much will the bill be?

Rhode Island’s 2015 plan for a carbon tax sounds remarkably similar to Vermont’s, in that it planned to “return 100% of revenue (minus overhead costs) in the form of rebates and programs.” However, rather than the 0% of revenues that ESSEX Carbon Tax insinuates, the R.I. proposal predicted 5% of revenues would go toward “administrative overhead costs” if it had been passed. Connecticut’s 2017 carbon tax proposal called for “not more than five per cent shall be used to pay for administrative costs.” Massachusetts does not give a cost estimate, but at least it admits that carbon tax would have administrative costs, while hoping to keep them “presumably low.” British Columbia’s carbon tax was promised to be revenue neutral before its passage in 2008, but it has become “revenue-negative because of administrative costs.”

The ESSEX plan will supposedly raise $240 million revenue. Assuming the 5% administrative costs’ figure that other states have used, Vermonters could end up paying bureaucrats around $12 million.

Additionally, the required annual audit will cost something too. The proposal’s wording is very precise- Vermont ratepayers won’t have to pay for the audit. But somebody will! On April 15th, if the ratepayers are spared the bill, Vermont taxpayers will have to pick up the tab. And since ratepayers are generally taxpayers, Vermonters in general will be worse off.

The situation recalls a scheme Homer Simpson in the Simpsons episode “Lard of the Dance.” Here Homer learns that people will pay money for grease. So, Homer decides to cook up all of the bacon in his fridge and sells 4 pounds of bacon grease for $0.63 (he feeds all of the bacon to his dog, which gets sick). Then, Homer’s son Bart decides to question Homer’s actions:

Bart: “Dad, all that bacon cost $27.”

Homer: “Yeah, but your mom paid for that.”

Bart: “Doesn’t she get her money from you?”

Homer: “And I get my money from grease, what’s the problem?”

If proponents of the ESSEX plan want to be taken seriously, they should admit that the ESSEX plan will, at best, cost millions in administrative and auditing costs. As such, the plan is not really revenue neutral. Overall, this latest version of the Carbon Tax will require Vermonters to spend more in taxes than will be returned in rebates. As Homer would say, “D’oh!”

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.
Read more...

Latest News

The Quebec Election

October 18, 2018 by John McClaughry Most Vermonters live within an hour’s drive of Quebec, Canada, yet it’s astonishing how little we know about events taking place in...

School choice, not Pre-K, key to attracting young families

October 16, 2018 by Rob Roper In their recent debate, Governor Scott and democratic candidate Christine Hallquist both expressed their policy preference for expanding government-run pre-k programs. Scott...

Why Venezuela Matters

October 15, 2018  By John J. Metzler UNITED NATIONS—It didn’t have to be this way.  An oil rich, economically prosperous middle class country, once a stable Latin American...

EAI Comments on Individual Mandate Working Group draft report

  October 11, 2018 Herewith are our comments on the Working Group’s draft product. The legislature is concerned that with the repeal of the Obamacare insurance mandate, individual...

High Minimum Wages Were Designed to Hurt Minorities

October 5, 2018 by Rob Roper With institutional racism becoming an increasingly discussed topic in Vermont, it is ironic that some of our legislators are again promising to...

Video