Commentary: Paid sick leave a cynical issue for 2016 (September, 2015)

By Rob RoperRob Roper

At a recent press conference Governor Shumlin and Speaker of the House (and gubernatorial candidate) Shap Smith, flanked by some “socially responsible” businesses called for a new law mandating that all employees offer a paid sick leave benefit to their employees. This issue will be at the top of the priority list when the legislature returns to Montpelier in January.

This is essentially a $14 million tax on poor, small financially vulnerable enterprises throughout Vermont. It’s also a pretty cynical move on the part of the folks advocating for it.

Let me say straight away that offering some sort of paid time off to recover from a cold or deal with a personal issue is a smart benefit for any businesses to voluntarily offer for the purposes of enticing and keeping quality employees. And, most do one way or another, formally and/or informally.

Those that don’t – and this is where our politicians either don’t understand or don’t care – simply can’t afford it.  It’s much like purchasing health insurance. Very few would argue it’s a bad idea to purchase health insurance. Over 90 percent of Vermonters have it. The fraction of people who don’t have it don’t have it because they genuinely don’t have the money to buy it. The same is true of small business that genuinely can’t afford to pay people who aren’t working.

The legislature seems to think that every business has an endless source of cash stuffed in treasure chests hidden away in the attic. The truth is that small businesses are, like people, diverse. Some are poor, operating hand to mouth and struggling each month to make payroll. This can be particularly true of entrepreneurial businesses that are just starting out. Many owners of such businesses don’t make much more, or even make less than, their employees. Mandates such as this come directly out of their take home pay.

Do we want someone with the flu making our sandwich at the local deli, or looking after of our kids when we drop them off at daycare? Of course not. But we also have to recognize that the deli or the daycare provider may only have enough money on hand to pay one person to prepare the food or look after the children, and not enough to pay a temporary replacement plus the person calling in sick. Is that unfortunate? Yes. Is it reality? Also yes.

So, why is this paid sick leave mandate a cynical ploy on behalf of its advocates?

First, this announcement by the governor and speaker ironically came about the same time that Governor Shumlin called for the legislature to prepare for level funded budgets in 2016. If the state recognizes that it can’t afford to do more than it’s currently doing, why can’t they recognize that many small business may be in exactly the same boat? This is really just a way to levy a hidden $14 million “tax” without having to call it that or be accountable for it in an election year.

It is cynical on the part of those “socially responsible” businesses because the ones advocating for paid sick leave already offer it. It’s no skin off their bottom line if the mandate passes – but it will knee-cap their competition by saddling them with a cost they can’t afford. Maybe even knock the competition out of business. These folks get to appear all high and noble on the stage wile actually putting the screws to the upstart entrepreneur next door.

If these politicians and established businesses really think all employees should automatically receive compensation for days they do not work then the state should raise $14 million in new taxes (or cut other programs), establish a transparent and accountable program, and write checks to those workers or their employers based on financial need.

I wonder how those “socially responsible” businesses would respond to implementing something like the current health care claims assessment, taxing them each time they pay out a sick leave benefit to an employee with the proceeds going to help other businesses that are struggling financially and genuinely cannot afford to offer paid sick leave on their own? I suspect their tune would change dramatically.

Mandating hidden taxes like this is cowardly, as well as bad policy. A survey by Vermont Business Magazine recently revealed that 20% of small- to medium-sized business owners in Vermont have “put plans in motion during the past 12 months to move their residency outside Vermont,” and 45% of respondents to the survey have considered moving. Is it any wonder?

{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

Robert Carman October 1, 2015 at 12:58 pm

Ultimately the employee will be funding their own paid leave. How? By a lower wage and this adjustment will come through delayed or smaller pay increases

Already the large amount of mandated costs the employer must pay is nuts.

This is also something that will definitely be abided. People will stay home to use up their sick leave on days they want to do something. Then when they are sick , they will be working because they will have used up their sick time.

To be absolutely blunt, the vast majority of our politicians are relatively stupid but then that is the nature of a politician anyway. There is seldom a truly intelligent politician.


Jim Bulmer October 1, 2015 at 2:26 pm

Democrat law makers in Montpelier have always committed monies without giving any thought as to how these commitments can be honored simply because they could care less. At the end of the day, they know when all else fails they can and will raise taxes. And Vermonters wonder how we got into this mess?


Mark Candon October 1, 2015 at 3:30 pm

The state was granted an exemption from this law and the House refused to allow an amendment to reverse. Check out the roll call in the House Journal of April 23, 2015. “Cynical” barely meets their level of contempt.


Cancel reply

Leave a Comment

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.

Latest News

Roll Call! Senate Passes Revised Global Warming Solutions Act (23-5), 2020

H.688 – AN ACT RELATING TO ADDRESSING CLIMATE CHANGE PASSEDin the State Senateon June 26, 2020, by a vote of23-5 Purpose: The Global Warming Solutions Act (GWSA) mandates...

Roll Call! Senate Passes Paid Family Leave (20-9), 2020

H.107 – AN ACT RELATING TO PAID FAMILY AND MEDICAL LEAVE PASSED in the State Senate on January 17, 2020by a vote of  20-9  . Purpose: To put in place...

Grants to Determine Who Survives and Dies in VT Healthcare

Vermont is learning that starting and stopping the economy is anything but easy. The most glaring issue is that when the economy does come back, many organizations (most...

Roll Call! House Votes for Legislator Pay Raise (82-61), 2020


We’re Beyond the Canaries, Coal Miners are Dropping

June 24, 2020 by Rob Roper This week we learned that two stalwart Vermont companies are cutting jobs due to the Covid-19 economic shutdown, and an iconic Vermont...