Commentary: All Payer Waiver Puts Medicare in Crosshairs

By Darcie Johnston

All-Payer Waiver:  Remember the major brouhaha last year when word leaked that the Shumlin administration was trying to pull Vermonters’ Medicare into their single payer health care scheme?  The administration roundly denied it over – and over – and over again. Robin Lunge, Shumlin’s Director of Health Care Reform must have denied it ten different ways; most notably, “We’re not going to change Vermonters’ Medicare benefits.”   Well yes, you are.  And here’s how.

The Shumlin administration has been pursuing an “All-Payer Waiver” from the Feds for at least the past year.   The waiver would eliminate the current fee-for-service payment model used by physicians.  All payment rates, including Medicare’s, would be rolled into a single payment system run by the Green Mountain Care Board.  The GMCB would control Vermonters’ Medicare funds, and would set the rates that Medicare will reimburse docs and hospitals.  This system would replace the current Federal Medicare payment system for Vermont’s seniors.

VHCF believes that an all-payer waiver is a slippery slope to a single payer health care system.  Under single payer, the state would provide the only health care plan that residents could use. Under an all-payer waiver, private insurance plans would remain, but provider reimbursement rates would be set at the same level for all plans.

There is a very real concern that Vermont seniors will not be able to find the care they need here in Vermont,   because the state’s all-payer waiver and tinkering with Medicare reimbursements will drive out physicians, who can practice in other states without the restraints.

Additionally, if the state controlled Medicare funds, what would happen to seniors who travel or seek health care out of state?  Docs and hospitals across the country will take “regular” Federal Medicare, but would they accept “Vermont” Medicare, which is likely to pay less?  Would they even know what “Vermont” Medicare is?  Don’t forget – the whole idea is for Vermont to pay less than would otherwise be paid.

The Shumlin administration is well-known for dealing in half-truths.  The half- truth here is that sure, we won‘t change your Medicare benefits, but good luck getting those benefits either  in Vermont or elsewhere in the country. Vermont seniors deserve the assurance that no matter where they go, their Medicare benefits are safe and intact.

S.139 includes $862,767 in funds to pursue an all-payer waiver, of which $184,636 is General Fund money.   The Green Mountain Care Board’s authority is increased and it gets another three positions.

On April 30th Reps.. Morrissey and Browning offered an amendment to S.139 to strip from Act 48 the requirement that “Green Mountain Care shall assume responsibility for the benefits and services previously paid for by the federal programs, including Medicare.”  The Democrats and Progressives defeated it on almost a straight party line vote 54-85.

- This is a guest Commentary by Darcie Johnston, Executive Director of Vermonters for Healthcare Freedom.

{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

Ray Fotion June 1, 2015 at 9:13 pm

I am a REGISTERED VOTER, and an Independent. My Vote will ONLY go to whom ever OPPOSES the Spendocrats and the present Socialists in Mont– pecu LIAR. LEAVE MY MEDICARE ALONE!!! Ray Fotion Newbury , Vt.

Reply

Mike Powers June 1, 2015 at 9:17 pm

The worst possible idea. Vermont is not capable of administering Medicare benefits and most certainly any out of state benefits would present a insurmountable obstacle. Why does Vt always think it should have programs that run contrary to the rest of the country. And don’t site the plan in Maryland which does not mirror the Vermont proposal. This state is absolutely bent on driving out its citizens by tax grabs and veiled program proposals that resented as one thing which are actually another thing entirely. Totally unrealistic proposal.

Reply

Mary Daly June 2, 2015 at 11:44 am

I agree with Mr. Fotion’s statement above, “Leave my Medicare alone.” Or better yet, “Keep your cotton picking phalanges (fingers) out of my Medicare.”

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.
Read more...

Latest News

William Galston on Sanders’ single payer

by John McClaughry William Galston, a White House advisor in the Clinton years, is the thoughtful moderate Democrat columnist for the Wall Street Journal. He had a piece...

Sanderscare: What is Bernie Thinking?

by David Flemming Once again, Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders has decided to beat the drum for single-payer healthcare (Medicare for All!) Will he ever realize he’s beating a...

Mathis Forgets G.I. Bill Was A Voucher Program

by Bruce Buxton This piece is a response to an Op-Ed by William Mathis of the Vermont State School Board, which can be read HERE.  Mr. Mathis is...

Are We Paying Parents to Keep Kids In Poverty?

by Rob Roper An article in Seven Days reminded us that back in 2007 the Vermont legislature set a goal to cut child poverty in half in ten...

Advocate: Raise Minimum Wage Till It Hurts!

by David Flemming On Sept. 6, David Cooper of the Economic Policy Institute (a Left leaning, Washington-based think tank founded by a coalition of eight labor unions) testified...

Video