Commentary: A New Chapter in Crony Capitalism (June 2014)

by John McClaughryJohn McClaughry

Gov. Peter Shumlin has announced the latest in a long series of sweet deals for his favored people at everybody else’s expense. The lucky winner is IBM, which has repeatedly been reported as preparing to unload its Essex Jct. plant and departing Vermont.

This latest deal is a three year electricity rate freeze. As reported on Vermont Digger, “The proposed three-year rate freeze for IBM is an incentive to keep the company in the state, state officials say. If electricity prices rise in the next three years, Green Mountain Power will cover any costs associated with that rate freeze. GMP and the state say the deal is good for ratepayers.” Presumably the rate frozen will be the rate in effect after a 2.46% reduction in rates set to take effect on October 1.

Gov. Shumlin said “the agreement provides stability and predictability for one of our most valued employers, and helps ensure that Vermont maintains a thriving center of innovation and technology well into the future.”

Well, let’s see. Shumlin and GMP agree that protecting IBM’s electricity rates is a good deal for ratepayers. But that’s only in the sense that having IBM in Vermont is a good deal for the Vermont economy generally. If power rates don’t go up, the deal doesn’t have any value. If they do go up, Vermont ratepayers not named IBM will see their rates go up, but those named IBM will get to pay the old, lower rates.

Will rates go up? That could happen because of rising natural gas prices, increased regional energy demand, Obama’s efforts to shut down coal-fired electricity, or another round of Shumlin’s renewable energy subsidies billed to Vermont ratepayers for the benefit of people who sell solar, wind and biogas electricity.

The announcement states that “GMP will cover any costs associated with that rate freeze.” With what?

Does GMP somewhere have a corporate reserve to cover the cost of the discount enjoyed by IBM? Probably not.

Will GMP use the $21 million snatched away from the CVPS ratepayers in the Shumlin-brokered utility merger of 2012? Most likely much of that has already been assigned to the GMP Community Energy and Efficiency Development Fund created to support Shumlin’s pet causes, weatherization and renewable energy subsidies.

Or will GMP cover any future discount by joining Shumlin’s Public Service Department in persuading the compliant Public Service Board to approve higher electricity rates for everybody else? That’s clearly the most likely alternative.

Commissioner Chris Recchia of the Department of Public Service is already on the band wagon. Though the freeze doesn’t prevent IBM from leaving the state, he said, “I think they would describe it as, every little bit helps.” Especially when every little bit is paid for by somebody else.

This latest corporate handout comes on top of the new $4.5 million Vermont Enterprise Incentive Fund created by the legislature at Shumlin’s behest to allow him to support any company on the verge of closing or leaving the state. The new deal is potentially much better for IBM, since Shumlin could hardly lavish the entire $4.5 million on IBM alone, and if he did, it would scarcely make any difference in the company’s decision making.

Maybe we ought to offer the same deal to our smaller business ratepayers. If you agree to stay in Vermont for three more years, you get the benefit of an electricity rate freeze. Quite a few would be willing to take that deal – but their Governor has arranged it only for Big Blue. Sorry.

IBM employs roughly 4,000 people with an estimated annual payroll of $150 to $200 million. The company is an incomparable asset to the state’s economy. But for Shumlin to engineer a special deal for IBM, that no other business can qualify for, adds yet another chapter to the (unsavory) “History of Crony Capitalism in Vermont”.

- John McClaughry is vice president of the Ethan Allen Institute (www.ethanallen.org)


The Ethan Allen Institute is a 501c3 non profit organization dedicated to promoting liberty and free market solutions for Vermont. We are supported by small, local donors such as yourself. Join the Cause. Be part of the solution! JOIN HERE! Contributions are tax deductible.

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.
Read more...

Latest News

Tax Plan, Schmax Plan: It’s The Spending, Stupid

by Chris Campion The GOP has recently been working on tax reform, and both the House and Senate have versions of tax reform that are currently being hashed...

Renewable Policies Responsible for GMP’s $80 million rate increase

by Guy Page Green Mountain Power’s proposed 2018 5% rate increase will cost ratepayers $80 million, Vermontbiz.com said November 27. GMP spokesperson Kristen Carlson blames the hike on increased transmission, regional...

Exxon Mobil ‘s “Green Preening”

by John McClaughry Here’s a news item some will find surprising. The American Legislative Exchange Council is a conservative business-oriented association of legislators and corporation interests. Recently it...

New Hampshire Lowers Taxes, Raises Revenue

by Rob Roper The New Hampshire Union Leader recently posted an editorial about their legislature’s 2015 decision to cut taxes on New Hampshire businesses. The tax cuts are...

Survey: Do You Support the ESSEX Carbon Tax Proposal

TAKE THE SURVEY! Do you support the new “ESSEX” Carbon Tax proposal? This would ultimately be a $240 million tax on gasoline (32¢/gal), heating oil and diesel fuel...

Video