Civil Forfeiture: Standing Up To Government Theft

By John McClaughry

Damon Root, writing at Reason.com, reports that the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has joined Justice Clarence Thomas’s war against civil forfeiture.

Earlier, Justice Thomas had penned a stinging dissent in the Supreme Court’s refusal to grant a hearing in a case where Texas police seized two hundred thousand dollars from Lisa Leonard but never charged her or anyone in her family with a crime.

Last week the D.C. Circuit signaled its agreement with Thomas in a decision in favor of an innocent couple fighting for the return of $17,900 in cash seized by the police, although no underlying criminal charges were ever filed. But when two women whose money it was requested its return, a federal district judge ruled that they lacked standing, thus ending their case and leaving the government in possession of their cash.

The D.C. Circuit reversed. Describing the legal process that led to this result as “onerous, unfair, and unrealistic,” it ruled that “The pair has a right to contest whether the money is subject to forfeiture. Despite the government’s best efforts, this will remain an adversary proceeding.” Now that their standing to bring suit has been recognized, the two robbery victims will continue their legal battle to get their money back.

Civil forfeiture abuse is one of government’s worst practices, and it needs to be decisively stopped. Here’s a gold star for Justice Thomas for his principled stand to stop it.

John McClaughry is vice president of the Ethan Allen Institute

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.
Read more...

Latest News

Are We Paying Parents to Keep Kids In Poverty?

by Rob Roper An article in Seven Days reminded us that back in 2007 the Vermont legislature set a goal to cut child poverty in half in ten...

Advocate: Raise Minimum Wage Till It Hurts!

by David Flemming On Sept. 6, David Cooper of the Economic Policy Institute (a Left leaning, Washington-based think tank founded by a coalition of eight labor unions) testified...

Vermont Public Schools Are Failing Most Vulnerable Students

by Rob Roper  The latest standardized test results are out, and the results are pretty disappointing. Overall, scores dropped a bit from where they were last year, and,...

Were Vermonters Voting In New Hampshire?

by Rob Roper The New Hampshire Speaker of the House released data showing that over 5000 people registered to vote in New Hampshire for the 2016 election using...

North Korean Noose Tightens?

by John J. Metzler UNITED NATIONS—Will there be conflict on the Korean peninsula? Shall the long simmering tinderbox finally explode in a nuclear flash? Or shall everybody step...

Video