12-17-14 – Who gets to decide what we can afford?

posted by Rob Roper

Paul Cillo of the Public Assets Institute posted remarks he made at the Vermont Digger forum on education finance crisis. He opened by saying, “What crisis?” then launched into series of charts, graphs and equations that illustrated, to his thinking, how Vermont’s spending on K-12 education is a model of sustainability that we should all be delighted with.

The numbers are well and good (though arguably cherry picked), but ignores the fact that on the campaign trail every candidate I heard from said that property taxes were the number one concern of their constituents. Imagine going into your doctor’s office complaining of severe chest pains only to have the MD tell you you’re wrong. You’re not in pain at all. Get outta here. You’d hit him over the head with that little rubber mallet they use to test your reflexes! Or at least you’d be tempted to.

Which gets us to the moral crux of this issue (and long time pet political peeve of mine). We so often hear left-wing politicians saying that they’re just “asking” taxpayers who “can afford to pay a little more,” so get out your wallet and pony up. First of all, they’re not asking. They’re taking the money, and using government’s monopoly on “legitimate” violence to do so. Second, who are they to be telling us what we can afford?

My 14-year-old son keeps insisting I can afford a fancy sports car. (If only I’d pay my fair share!) Maybe… if we downsized our house, and stopped putting money into his college fund, and somebody put a gun to my head perhaps we could buy it. But it’s not a good use of resources, and I am not willing to spend money on that. And that’s the key word people like Cillo and too many legislators in Montpelier aren’t interested: willing.

In a system based on political power coming from the consent of the governed, “willing” must accompany “able.” Willing and able. Each individual has different priorities. We are all trying to feed our families, put roofs over our heads and pursue happiness where and when we can.

So, it doesn’t matter, as Cillo points out as his exhibit A, that education spending has held relatively steady between 5% and 6% of Gross State Product. What matters is how that reflects in the bill each of us gets every quarter and how big (and bigger) a bite it takes out of our disposable income. Clearly, the current amount is more than a majority of us is willing and able to pay.

Policy makers who don’t realize that are not listening to the people they represent.

- Rob Roper is president of the Ethan Allen Institute

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

About Us

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont’s free-market public policy research and education organization. Founded in 1993, we are one of fifty-plus similar but independent state-level, public policy organizations around the country which exchange ideas and information through the State Policy Network.
Read more...

Latest News

Iran’s Smoldering Fuse

By John J. Metzler UNITED NATIONS—Surging crowds thronged the streets of Tehran and cities across Iran screaming Death to the Shah, Death to America.  A revolutionary situation brewing...

Net Metering Program Driving Up Energy Bills

by Rob Roper  Green Mountain Power recently announced the need to raise its rates by 5%. Why? One growing reason is Vermont’s “Net Metering” program. The way Net...

Carbon Tax Rebate? Don’t Count On It.

by David Flemming Last November, environmental activists released the “ESSEX” Carbon Tax plan that called for legislation taxing fossil fuels and giving the money that was not used for...

Vermont’s Sad Education Test Scores

by John McClaughry Vermont Digger has done us another service by publishing a report entitled “Making the Grade?”. It presents the results of the tests used by Vermont...

Report: Vermont Spending Way Too Much On Special Education

by Rob Roper This week at the State House, Tammy Kolbe, an Assistant Professor at the University of Vermont, spoke to a joint meeting of the House and...

Video